Abstracts
55
operative-time length. Three parameters were evaluated: devia-
tion of the postoperative bone segment position compared to the
preoperative planning expressed in mm (
Δ
); overall rough costs
of preoperative planning, and average operative time length (OR).
The discrepancy between the planned tridimensional graft position
and the actual bone location was measured by superimposing the
postoperative CT scan with the virtual plan when available, oth-
erwise was judged on the basis of recognisable landmarks (such
as the condylar position or the mandibular angle) on postopera-
tive images. The costs of non-digital planning were estimated by
adding the costs of materials and procedures (three-dimensional
printing, resin, and alginate) to the honorary of competency
involved in the planning.
Results:
The accuracy of the postoperative result in rela-
tion to the planning method showed a
Δ
= 7.2 mm (SD
1.6 mm) for manual drawing;
Δ
= 2 mm (0.6) for cast
modelling, and
Δ
= 1.5 mm for digital planning. The
overall rough costs ranged $5000–7000 for digital mod-
elling, depending on the use of pre-bended or customised
milled reconstruction plate, $1500–2000 for cast modelling
and were inconspicuous for the manual drawing planning
method. The average OR was 447 min, 540 min, and 387 min for
manual drawing, model cast, and digital planning respectively.
Conclusion:
The review of 15 years of mandibular reconstruc-
tion using fibula and iliac crest free flaps showed the evolution
of planning-techniques, highlighting the differences between dif-
ferent periods and Institutions. Despite the intrinsic difficulty in
drawing a solid conclusion by comparing different times and
work environments, what emerged is that it is possible to achieve
predictable and satisfactory results with different strategies of
planning. The modern use of computer-aided planning, by soft-
ware manipulation of the patient imaging, grants extreme accuracy
with reduced planning-time, but it is most expensive. The other
planning techniques described were less accurate and required
longer planning time, but were more cost effective and did not
require high technology tools. Regarding the operative time,
despite the theoretical advantage given by the use of cutting guides
and custom-made hardware, their use did not correlate with a
reduction of time of surgery; the operative time seemed rather be
influenced by the experience of operators and the harmonic and
well-coordinated team-work between resection and reconstructive
teams.
Reference
1 Hidalgo, D. A. (1989). Fibula free flap: a new method of mandible recon-
struction.
Plast Reconstr Surg
,
84
, 71–79.
2 Cordeiro, P. G., & Hidalgo, D. A. (1995). Conceptual considerations in
mandibular reconstruction.
Clin Plast Surg
,
22
, 61–69.
3 Metzler, P., Geiger, E. J., Alcon, A., Max, X., & Steinbacher, D. M. (2014).
Three-dimensional virtual surgery accuracy for free fibula mandibular
reconstruction: planned versus actual results.
J Oral Maxillofac Surg
,
72
,
2601–2612.
4 Man, Q. W., Jia, J., Liu, K., Chen, G., & Liu, B. J. (2015). Sec-
ondary reconstruction for mandibular osteoradionecrosis defect with fibula
osteomyocutaneous flap flowthrough from radial forearm flap using stere-
olithographic 3-dimensional printing modeling technology.
Craniofac
Surg
,
26
, e190–e193.
5 Tarsitano, A., Del Corso, G., Ciocca, L., Scotti, R., &Marchetti, C. (2015).
Mandibular reconstructions using computer-aided design/computer-aided
manufacturing: a systematic review of a defect-based reconstructive algo-
rithm.
J Craniomaxillofac Surg
,
43
, 1785–1791.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijom.2017.02.200Hybrid maxillomandibular fixation: initial cost analysis
M.D. Turner
Icahn Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York, NY, United
States
Background:
The application of maxillomandibular fixation
(MMF) is central to the management of mandibular fractures.
MMF can either be achieved utilising a teeth borne system or
a bone borne system. Hybrid MMF is a newer bone borne system
that anchors an arch bar, utilising screws, into the alveolar process.
Objectives:
To present initial data on operating room time versus
operating room costs in regards to the use of hybrid MMF.
Methods:
A retrospective case study was conducted over a three-
year period at Jacobi Medical Center. Patients with mandible
fractures that were treated with open reduction internal fixation
(ORIF), were divided into two cohorts, depending on whether
they had Erich arch bars (EAB) or hybrid MMF (HYB) placed.
There were 48 patients in the EAB cohort and 52 in the HYB.
Patients were excluded if they did not have the same appliance on
each arch.
Findings:
When comparing the operating room time in the treat-
ment of mandible fractures, the average surgical time was 211 min
in the EAB cohort and 132 min in the HYB cohort, a decrease in
79 min. At Jacobi Medical Center, each 10-min unit of time in the
operating room, cost $391, so a decrease in 79 min of operating
room time resulted in a decrease in cost of $3128. The cost of each
hybrid arch bar at Jacobi Medical Center is $220, with 6 screws
placed in each arch at a cost of $100/screw. The total cost of the
placement of two hybrid arch bars and 12 screws was $1640. The
sum cost saving was $1488.
Conclusions:
Utilising a hybrid MMF system in the management
of mandibular fractures undergoing ORIF decreased the operating
room time by 37.4%. This decrease in operating room time, even
when factoring in the cost of the hardware, decreased the overall
cost of the surgery.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ijom.2017.02.201Skeletal surgery for craniofacial microsomia
T.A. Turvey
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, United States
Craniofacial microsomia (CFM) is a facial clefting condition
affecting both the soft and hard tissues of the face and it is the
second most frequently encountered facial clefting condition (1 in
50,000 live births). The condition is very variable and is usually
unilateral but bilateral expression can also be seen. The classi-
fication of CFM is usually based on the degree of mandibular
malformation which is not related to the degree of ear malforma-
tion or soft tissue hypoplasia.
The algorithm of construction proposed by Converse remains
unchanged today other than the potential for early mandibular dis-
traction for correction of airway issues. Although some advocate
distraction osteogenesis as a substitute for early skeletal surgery,
there is no evidence to suggest the superiority of this approach and
in light of the lack of control, scarring, etc. there are potentially
disadvantages to this approach.
Once the patient has operable bone stock, conventional
orthognathic surgery predictably can be accomplished with little
morbidity and less dependency on patient and parent compliance
compared to distraction techniques. Maxillary and mandibu-
lar osteotomies and bone grafting for augmentation as well as




